SEO is full of conflicting advice, but what truly drives traffic growth? To find out, Ryan G. Jones analyzed 131 SEO tests on the SEOTesting platform, sharing his findings in a LinkedIn post (source). The results revealed which strategies lead to measurable increases in clicks and rankings—and which tactics can actually hurt performance.
This post breaks down the most effective SEO techniques, the strategies that failed, and the key takeaways that will help you optimize your site with confidence. If you’re looking to improve your content, internal links, or video integration, understanding these insights will help you avoid common pitfalls and maximize your traffic potential.
What Actually Moves the Needle in SEO? Insights from 131 SEO Tests
1. Refreshing Content Boosts SEO Performance
One of the biggest wins from the tests was content updates. Refreshing old articles by adding new information, sections, and keywords increased clicks by an average of 44%.
How to Update Content for SEO Gains
- Identify outdated pages: Use Google Search Console or Ahrefs to find pages with declining traffic.
- Expand existing content: Add new insights, case studies, or updated stats to improve relevance.
- Improve readability: Break long paragraphs, add bullet points, and enhance user experience.
- Refresh keyword targeting: Analyze current search trends and optimize for user intent.
Example:
A finance website updated an old tax guide with new 2024 regulations and saw a 58% increase in traffic in three months.
2. Strategic Internal Linking Lifts Traffic by 29%
Internal linking isn’t just about navigation—it significantly impacts SEO rankings. The tests showed that strategic internal linking increased traffic by an average of 29% when done correctly.
Best Practices for Internal Linking
- Prioritize high-value pages: Link to pages that need more visibility and authority.
- Use keyword-rich anchor text: Keep links relevant and descriptive without over-optimizing.
- Fix broken links: Broken internal links harm user experience and rankings.
Example:
An e-commerce site fixed broken internal links on product pages and gained 1,600 extra clicks in a few weeks.
3. Embedding Videos Can Skyrocket Clicks (or Hurt SEO)
Videos can dramatically boost engagement, but the results were hit-or-miss. Some pages saw a 5,000% increase in clicks, while others lost up to 65% of their traffic.
When Video Helps SEO
- Enhances user experience: Videos like tutorials or product demos keep visitors engaged.
- Hosted on YouTube: Embedding YouTube videos helped maintain page speed.
- Optimized for search: Including transcripts, captions, and structured data improved rankings.
When Video Hurts SEO
- If it slows down page speed: Large video files can harm performance.
- If it’s irrelevant to the page: Unrelated videos decreased engagement and increased bounce rates.
Example:
A travel blog added high-quality destination videos on location pages and saw a 350% increase in time-on-page and click-through rates.
4. Title Tweaks Can Increase Clicks—But They’re Risky
Changing page titles is one of the simplest SEO tweaks, yet it doesn’t always work. While some title optimizations led to a 13% boost in clicks, others caused traffic losses of up to 60%.
TBest Practices for Title Optimization
- Match search intent: Ensure titles align with user expectations.
- Test before scaling: Run A/B tests before applying changes sitewide.
- Use emotional triggers: Words like “best,” “proven,” and “ultimate” can increase CTR.
- Avoid misleading titles: Clickbait-style headlines may increase bounces.
Example:
A tech site changed a blog title from “Best Laptops for Work” to “Top 10 Work Laptops Ranked (2024)” and saw a 21% increase in organic clicks.
5. Meta Description Tweaks Have Little Impact
Contrary to common belief, updating meta descriptions alone had minimal impact on organic traffic. While a strong meta description can improve CTR, it doesn’t directly influence rankings.
HWhen Meta Descriptions Matter
- For competitive search results: A compelling description attracts clicks in crowded SERPs.
- For brand messaging: It helps shape how your content is perceived in search results.
Example:
A SaaS company improved its click-through rate by 8% by making meta descriptions more engaging and benefit-focused—but rankings remained unchanged.
What We Learned from 131 SEO Tests
1. Content is still king – Regular updates and expansions deliver the most consistent SEO wins.
2. Internal links matter – Fixing gaps or pointing links to key pages can drive real traffic growth.
3. Title changes are high-risk – Always test before implementing sitewide changes.
4. Video can be a gamechanger – But only if used strategically to enhance user experience.
5. SEO is unpredictable – Even “best practices” don’t always work. Testing is essential.
These findings reinforce that SEO success isn’t about following general advice—it’s about testing, analyzing data, and making informed decisions.
SEO isn’t a one-size-fits-all strategy. What works for one website may not work for another. The key to success is constant experimentation and data-driven adjustments.Instead of relying on outdated SEO myths, test what works for your site and adapt accordingly. Whether it’s refreshing content, optimizing internal links, or tweaking titles, the real winners in SEO are those who continuously experiment and refine their approach
Looking for a Powerful Growth Marketing Strategy for Your SaaS Business?
At SaaSlaunchr, I specialize in creating innovative and results-driven marketing strategies tailored to boost growth for scaling SaaS companies. Let’s collaborate to take your business to the next level! Schedule a call with me today to learn more about how I can support your success.
Curious about the impact we can make? Check out our success story on how we helped a SaaS business significantly increase website traffic by implementing a strategic growth marketing plan. Read the case study here.
Want More Insights?
Stay on top of the latest trends and strategies! Subscribe to our newsletter to receive updates and exclusive content directly in your inbox. Don’t miss out! 👇👇👇
